American Icons, Indexed

April 24, 2024.

by Bridget O’Donnell


Maybe you remember this writing prompt from grade school:

Describe how to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Be mindful when listing the instructions and don't assume that any step is too menial to mention. Once you're satisfied that everything is organized and in working order, follow your instructions.

  1. Collect your ingredients and arrange the sliced bread, peanut butter, and jelly within arms reach.
  2. Open the package of bread. Remove two slices and place them next to each other on a plate or clean surface.
  3. Open the container of peanut butter and put the lid down near you.
  4. Hold the container with your non-dominant hand then pick up a butter knife with your other hand and use it to remove some of the peanut butter.
  5. 'You can't tell me what to do!' hopefully isn't what you were starting to think, hahah.

For the sake of brevity, I came up with about fourteen steps. Try it on your own and feel free to complicate things. Substitute sliced bread for a bagel, roll or wrap. Use your favorite nut butter. Try honey instead of jelly. Crack open that jar of jam you canned last season or, slice some fresh fruit. Add more texture to each bite by including a layer of your favorite chips. There's no wrong answer; anything goes. The possibilities are only limited to the ingredients you have on hand. Peanut butter and jelly hasn’t been a regular part of my diet since college so we rarely have all of the ingredients on hand. In lieu, for this month's What's Cooking Blog, I substituted one iconic sandwich for another that's also equally as economical.


Title of cookbook/database: The New York Times Database - (Path: poklib.org / hold your mouse over the Learn tab / select Online Resources and Databases / select N or, scroll down to Newspapers, Magazines, & Journals.)

Author of Recipe: Julia Moskin

What prompted you to check out this recipe?

A coworker suggested that I look through the recipes in The New York Times for dinner ideas. While browsing the Cooking section in an online subscription, I came across a recipe that reminded me of a short conversation I had earlier that day. The local business owner I spoke with was 'looking forward to dinner because she didn't have to cook; her husband would have grilled cheese ready when she got home from work.' Interesting aside, some form of grilled cheese has been around since the early 1900s and, throughout history this affordable meal has also been referred to as a "cheese box," "toasted cheese," and during the Great Depression the “cheese dream.” (Wilcox 21) Serendipitously, the first recipe that I saw for grilled cheese linked to a handful of variations. Let’s just say, the sky’s the limit! Like PB&J, a grilled cheese sandwich not only has the capability to bring back memories, but can be versatile as well. It took some time to narrow my choices down to three simple recipes by Julia Moskin, Eric Kim, and Ali Slagle. Unfortunately, you'll need a personal subscription to access these recipes from The New York Times Cooking, but there are other recipes available through the library’s subscription of The New York Times database*.

After skimming some of those, I had to see for myself why almost every grilled cheese recipe made available by the New York Times suggested using mayonnaise.

 

*Access databases at any of the Poughkeepsie Public Library District locations. [Note: remote access to some databases may be limited while others are available throughout the Mid-Hudson Library System.]

What is a Database?

  • A Database is an index accessible through the internet; they aren’t webpages.
  • They can include published journals, magazines, newspapers, image collections, newsletters, yearbooks, comic books, etc.
  • The contents must meet specific collection criteria. For example, articles are edited and/or peer-reviewed.
  • Databases provide publication dates, bibliographic citations and some may provide links to full text.
  • They are not free; the library pays for a subscription.
  • Unlike a personal online subscription (to something like the New York Times, for example), database subscriptions do not include advertisements or, in some cases, the photographs/diagrams displayed in the original article.
  • There are different types of databases. They can be specialized with content about specific subjects or, general. There can be subtle nuances to searching databases as well as to how the information retrieved is formatted.

If you’re interested in learning how to use any of the databases PPLD subscribes to, contact us at the Adriance Memorial Library Reference Desk - 1-845-485-3445, x3702.

What did you like about this recipe?

Moskin provides a very general list of ingredients, four, to be exact: bread, butter, mayonnaise, grated cheddar or other cheese.

What didn’t you like about this recipe?

Does this American icon really need Mayonnaise and butter? I could probably even use a butter substitute if I turned down the heat and monitored the cook time. Honestly though, we don't eat grilled cheese often enough to experiment with every possible ingredient or method of cooking. Not only are there over 2,000 types of cheese in the world but, who knew you could broil grilled cheese in the oven? (Wilcox 176)

Also note, if you tend to choose what to eat by the photographs, you may be disappointed when you see how the database formats a recipe.

Favorite recipes (that you tried from the cookbook/website):

Grilled Cheese Sandwich.

Did you alter the recipe or make any substitutions?

Our grilled cheese was constructed on Sour dough. As suggested in a number of recipes, I arbitrarily mixed cheeses, melding shredded parmesan (a gift from our neighbor’s trip to Italy. Thank you, again!), gouda, and gruyere with a slice of cheddar but I could easily have included a stronger cheese and, maybe a slice of tomato. I also missed the step to melt cheese on both sides of the bread before sandwiching them in the pan. The fact that it didn't have a deleterious impact should be encouragement for any novice.👍🏻

Would you recommend this cookbook/database?

If you’re not pressed for time or looking for a specific recipe, try searching the database. Learning something new keeps your brain healthy and you never know when you may come across a[nother] classic.

 

Voila!


References:

Books - 

The Great Grilled Cheese Book: Grown-Up Recipes for a Childhood Classic / Eric Greenspan.

Great Book of Grilled Cheese: 100+ Recipes for the Ultimate Comfort Food, Soups, Salads, and Sides / Kim Wilcox. - (In addition to sides, desserts and condiments are included so readers can complete a grilled cheese meal. Read about “The Brief but Important History” of the iconic sandwich in Chapter 1 - Grilled Cheese Essentials, page 21.)

Databases -

Clark, Melissa. "Taking Back a Childhood Favorite." New York Times, 11 April 2007, p. F3(L). The New York Times,

link.gale.com/apps/doc/A161825361/SPN.SP01?u=nysl_se_pghkl&sid=bookmark-SPN.SP01&xid=32219480. Accessed 5 April 2024. - (Try to find another article by searching the following keywords: “grilled cheese.")

Websites -

“Cognitive Health and Older Adults | National Institute on Aging.” National Institute on Aging, www.nia.nih.gov/health/brain-health/cognitive-health-and-older-adults. Accessed 21 April 2024.

Kim, Eric. “Quick Tomato Soup with Grilled Cheese.” The New York Times, 29 January 2023, https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1022653-quick-tomato-soup-with-grilled-cheese?smid=url-share.

Member Libraries. Mid-Hudson Library System, https://midhudson.org/libraries/. Accessed 21 April 2024.

Moskin, Julia. “Grilled Cheese Sandwich.” The New York Times, 30 March 2015, https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1017326-grilled-cheese-sandwich?smid=url-share.

"Online Resources and Databases." Poughkeepsie Public Library District, https://poklib.org/learn/online-resources-databases/. Accessed 21 April 2024.

“Recipes and Cooking Guides from the New York Times.” The New York Times, https://cooking.nytimes.com/. Accessed 19 April 2024.

Sifton, Sam. “A Field Guide to the American Sandwich.” The New York Times, 14 April 2015, https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/04/14/dining/field-guide-to-the-sandwich.html.

Slagle, Ali. “Grilled Cheese Sandwich on the Grill.” The New York Times, 30 August 2021,

https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1022513-grilled-cheese-sandwich-on-the-grill?smid=url-share.

Vogel, Janelle. “Instructional Writing; How To Make A PB&J.” That After School Life, https://thatafterschoollife.com/pbj.html. Accessed 18 April 2024.

Quick Subject/Concept links to the Discover Online Library catalog:

Brian health - (Results narrowed down by Age group: Adult; Literary Form: Non-fiction; Concepts/subjects/Themes: Mental health, Mind and body, Longevity, Self-care, Health)

Keyword search for: Grilled cheese - (Results narrowed down by Literary Form: Non-fiction; Concepts/subjects/Themes: Cooking (Cheese))

Mindful* - (Results narrowed down by Concepts/subjects/Themes: Mindfulness & Meditation, Inspiration & Personal Growth, Health & Fitness, Self-actualization (Psychology), Body, Mind & Spirit)